Perfectionism and Sleep: Why You’re Losing Sleep Over Getting It ‘Right’

Let’s talk about perfectionism—because let’s be real, if you’re reading this, there’s a good chance you’re trying to figure out if you’re doing sleep right. Yes, sleep. The one biological function that’s supposed to happen automatically. And yet, here you are, wondering if you’re measuring up.

Welcome to the perfectionist’s guide to insomnia.

Perfectionism: The Sneaky Sleep Thief

If you’re a perfectionist, you already know it. You’re the one who re-reads emails 17 times before hitting send, re-arranges throw pillows like it’s an Olympic sport and maybe—just maybe—thinks sleep should be a skill you can master. Unfortunately sleep doesn’t work that way.

But perfectionists don’t like uncertainty. We crave control, predictability and clear outcomes. So when sleep doesn’t cooperate the natural instinct is to try harder. And therein lies the problem. Sleep isn’t a test you can study for nor is it a goal you can white-knuckle your way into achieving.

The ‘Gold Standard’ of Sleep (And Why It’s a Trap)

One of the biggest traps for perfectionists is the idea that there is a “right way” to sleep. You might think:

• I need exactly 8 hours of sleep to function.

• If I wake up in the middle of the night I’ve failed at sleeping.

• Everyone else seems to sleep just fine—why can’t I?

Let’s debunk this myth real quick: Sleep is not a performance. There is no gold medal for “Best Sleeper”. (And if there was, dogs would win every time and they don’t even try.)

But perfectionists love a benchmark so when you hear adults “should” get 7-9 hours of sleep you turn that into an all or nothing rule. Anything less than perfect feels like failure which creates stress. And stress? Well that’s the kryptonite of sleep.

The Comparison Game: The Fastest Route to Sleeplessness

Perfectionists also love to compare. And in today’s world that’s easier than ever. Social media makes sure of it. You see your friend posting about their “amazing 9 hours of sleep” while you lie awake, spiraling into a pit of self doubt, convinced you are broken.

A less frequent instagram story is “Tossed and turned from 2-4 AM and now I’m running on fumes.”  Just like with everything else, people share the highlight reel.

And even if they are sleeping well, so what? Their sleep has nothing to do with yours. Comparing sleep is like comparing fingerprints—unique to each person and completely pointless.

Where Perfectionism Comes From (And Why It Hijacks Sleep)

Perfectionism doesn’t come out of nowhere. It’s often rooted in:

• A need for control – If you can do everything “just right” you can control outcomes, right? (Spoiler: No.)

• A desire for stability – Uncertainty is uncomfortable so perfectionism tricks you into thinking predictability = safety.

• High standards from childhood – If you were praised for being “the responsible one” or got love from achievement, perfectionism may have become your coping strategy.

But here’s the kicker: Sleep thrives on letting go and perfectionism thrives on holding tight. See the conflict? The harder you try to force sleep the more it slips away.

Redefining Success: The ‘Window of Success’ Approach

So what’s the solution? If perfectionists need structure let’s give it to them—but in a way that actually works. Enter: The Window of Success.

Instead of aiming for perfect sleep (which doesn’t exist) define a range of acceptable outcomes. Instead of:

• I must get 8 hours of sleep, try Anywhere from 6 to 9 hours is fine.

• If I wake up in the middle of the night I’ve failed, try Waking up briefly is normal. As long as I get some solid sleep cycles I’m okay.

• I need to fall asleep in under 10 minutes, try Anywhere from 10-30 minutes is a reasonable time to fall asleep. If I'm not falling asleep I can get up and give it more time.This flexibility removes the pressure and, ironically, makes it easier to sleep. You’re not grading yourself on a pass/fail basis anymore—you’re allowing for a buffer which reduces stress and makes the process feel less like a high-stakes exam.

The Art of ‘Good Enough’ Sleep

If you take away one thing from this let it be this: You don’t have to be perfect at sleep for it to be restorative.

Think about food. You don’t need a gourmet meal every night to be nourished—sometimes a peanut butter sandwich gets the job done. Sleep works the same way. Some nights are better than others but as long as you’re getting enough rest most of the time you’re doing just fine.

So if you’re a perfectionist struggling with sleep consider this your permission slip to stop overthinking it. Trust that your body knows what to do. And remember: the best sleepers aren’t the ones who try the hardest—they’re the ones who don’t try at all.

---

 For more tips and professional support, visit www.sleep-anxiety.com. Fill out the contact form to schedule a free 15-minute consultation with Anissa Bell, LMFT, and find out if this treatment approach is right for you.